Carnival Game Supplies Costume Masks Dinosaur Party Theme Finger Puppets Luau Party Theme Miscellaneous Toys Pirate Party Theme Plush Toys Puffer Toys Rainbow Party Theme School Supplies Erasers School Supplies Pencils and Pens Toy Animals Toy Insects and Bugs Unicorn Party Theme Water Toys Yo-Yos
Ball Toys
best-seller
Carnival Game Supplies
Cats and Dogs
Costume Masks
Costumes and Accessories
Ducks
Easter Novelties
Erasers
extra bulky
Farm Animals
Figurines
Finger Puppets
Frogs
Games
Games and Puzzles
Inflatable Toys
Miscellaneous Animals
Miscellaneous Toys
Novelties
oversized/heavy
Party Themes
Party Themes - Dinosaur
Party Themes - Emoji
Party Themes - Insect
Party Themes - Luau Party
Party Themes - Mermaid
Party Themes - Monkey
Party Themes - Panda
Party Themes - Pirate Theme
Party Themes - Princess
Party Themes - Rainbow
Party Themes - Safari
Party Themes - Smile Face
Party Themes - Unicorn
Pencil Toppers
Pencils and Pens
Plush Toys
Puffer Toys
Reptiles
School Supplies
Squirt Toys
Stuffed Animals
theme: Alligator
theme: Alligators
theme: Animal
theme: Carnival
theme: Cat
theme: Cats
theme: Dinosaur
theme: Dog
theme: Dogs
theme: Dragon
theme: Dragons
theme: Ducks
theme: Easter
theme: Farm
theme: Insects
theme: Jungle
theme: Keychain
theme: Llama
theme: Luau
theme: Mermaids
theme: Pirate
theme: Plush
theme: Rainbow
theme: School
theme: Shark
theme: Sharks
theme: Smile
theme: Snake
theme: Snakes
theme: Summer
theme: Toy Animals
theme: Under the Sea
theme: Unicorn
theme: Woodland
Toy Animals
Toy Assortments
Toy Bugs
Toy Water Creatures
Toys
Water Toys
Wild Animals
Worms
Yo-Yos
Glamorous Unicorns Plush Toy (1 Dozen) Glamorous Unicorns Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
US Toy Glamorous Unicorns Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
$116.64
11 inches Long x 8 inches Tall Super soft plush material Assorted pink, purple and white colors Iridescent fabric horn All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Glamourous Unicorns (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! No fairy tale is complete without a magical unicorn. Tender and soft these unicorns will become the favorite stuffed animal for any princess. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party themeFind more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Glamourous Unicorns (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com is the perfect addition to any fairy tale. Adorable 11 inches Long x 8 inches Tall plush unicorns come in assorted pink, purple and white colors and feature an iridescent fabric horn. Super soft material makes them the perfect carnival redemption prize or gift for all ages. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day, packaged in a poly bag. Shop our Plush Toys category for more magical finds!
Dragons Plush Toys (One dozen)
US Toy Dragons Plush Toys (One dozen)
$48.60
13 inches Long from head to tail Assorted red, blue and green colors Plush Material All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Dragons (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These plush dragons are a great giveaway at a party or carnival. Each stuffed dragon features a scaly design. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party themeFind more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Our Plush Toys category features Dragons (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These fun, colorful dragons measure 13 inches long from head to tail and come in assorted red, blue and green colors. Soft and cuddly, they are perfect for all ages. They ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day, and come packaged 1 Piece in Poly Bag/1 Dozen in Poly Bag. Ideal for carnivals and parties, these plush dragons make a great giveaway prize that everyone will love!
Scaly Snakes Plush Toys (One dozen)
US Toy Scaly Snakes Plush Toys (One dozen)
$30.78
Size: 24 Inches Long Assorted red, blue and green scaly designs Plush material All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Scaly Snakes (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Scaly snakes that won't shed their skins. They like being cuddled to much for that. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party theme! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Add a bit of fun to your game with these Scaly Snakes (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These 24 inches long plush snakes come in assorted red, blue and green scaly designs and are sure to be a hit with all ages. Plus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day - so you can get them fast! With one piece in a poly bag and one dozen in a poly bag, you can easily stock up on these fun prizes. Get yours today and add a bit of excitement to your next event!
Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen)
US Toy Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen)
$8.10
3 1/4 Inches Wide x 4 Inches Long Felt Assorted wild animal designs including giraffe, zebra, lion, tiger, leopard, and elephant Ages 3 yrs+ Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! This wild animal finger puppet is perfect for pretend play. Celebrate in wild style with an animal print theme. Whether your theme is jungle, zoo, safari or wild animal we have the selection of party favors and costume accessories your need to make your adventure night a roaring success! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com is perfect for pretend play. These assorted wild animal designs including giraffe, zebra, lion, tiger, leopard, and elephant will bring your wild animal theme to life. Made from felt and measuring 3 1/4 inches Wide 4 inches Long, these finger puppets are the perfect party favor for ages 3 yrs+. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day, and arrives in a 9 inches Poly Bag w/ header. Shop CarnivalSource.com for more great items from our Plush Toys category!
Wild Animals with Velcro Hands Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
US Toy Wild Animals with Velcro Hands Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
$36.45
Highlights: 11 inches Tall Assortment includes: Tiger, Zebra, lion and Elephant Hook & loop palms Plush material All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Our Wild Animals with Velcro Hands (1 Dozen) is a perfect addition to any safari-themed party! Our 11 inch tall assortment includes a tiger, zebra, lion, and elephant, all with hook & loop palms. They are made of a plush material, perfect for all ages. Plus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Perfect for a school or church carnival or redemption center, these wild animals are the perfect prize for your next celebration. Get your set today!
Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen) Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen)
US Toy Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen)
$23.09
Size: 5 1/2 Inches Tall Sitting position Assorted red, blue, brown, gray, green and purple colors Plush material All Ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These plush bull dogs are begging for you to take them home. Sitting pretty as you please, these stuffed animal dogs are fun addition to any party favor bag. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party theme! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. This pack of Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs is the perfect prize or gift for any celebration! These adorable stuffed animals come in an assortment of colors including red, blue, brown, gray, green and purple. Measuring 5.5 inches tall and made of a soft plush material, these Bull Dogs are suitable for all ages. Plus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day! Perfect for party favor bags, carnival redemption prizes, and more! Get your Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs today from CarnivalSource.com!
Furry Farm Animals Plush Toys (one dozen) Furry Farm Animals Plush Toys (one dozen)
US Toy Furry Farm Animals Plush Toys (one dozen)
$19.44
5 inches Tall Assortment includes cow, pig, bunny rabbit and dog Plush material All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Furry Farm Animals (one dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These plush farm animals will melt your heart. Round up these cows, pigs, bunnies and puppy dogs bring them home to their new barn. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party themeFind more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. This dozen of furry farm animals is the perfect addition to any carnival or party game! Include a cow, pig, bunny rabbit, and dog, these adorable plush animals are sure to make your guests smile. Standing 5 inches tall and made of luxurious material, they are suitable for all ages and will ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Perfect as a gift or prize, these furry friends are sure to be a hit at any event! Shop CarnivalSource.com for more great items from our Plush Toys category.
Smiley Face Plush Toys (pack of 12)
US Toy Smiley Face Plush Toys (pack of 12)
$8.10
Size: 3 Inches in Diameter Assorted colors Made of plush All Ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Smiley Face Plush (pack of 12) by CarnivalSource.com! Always have a smiling face with these happy faces plush. Great for emoji themed parties, these small stuffed toys are the perfect party favor giveaway. They easily slip on your key chain or use them as a backpack pull. Wherever you go, happiness is sure to follow. Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Add smiles to your collection with CarnivalSource.com's Smiley Face Plush (pack of 12). These 3 inch diameter plush toys come in assorted colors and are sure to bring joy to all ages. Perfect for emoji themed parties and backpack pulls, these plush toys are sure to make everyone smile. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day and comes packaged in a poly bag with a UPC. Brighten up your day with these happy faces in our Plush Toys category.
Sitting Dogs Plush Toy (one dozen) Sitting Dogs Plush Toy (one dozen)
US Toy Sitting Dogs Plush Toy (one dozen)
$30.38
5 inches Tall Assorted gray, black and brown colors Plush material All Ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Sitting Dogs (one dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! This plush dog was designed for the smallest of dog lovers. The plush dogs come in assorted colors with contrasting feet. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party themeFind more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. These Sitting Dogs (one dozen) by CarnivalSource.com are perfect for any party or carnival game! The 5-inch tall plush dogs come in assorted gray, black, and brown colors and are sure to be a hit with kids of all ages. The soft material makes them the perfect cuddly prize or gift. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day. Get your dozen today and keep the fun going!
Plush Toy Mini Bears (One Dozen)
US Toy Plush Toy Mini Bears (One Dozen)
$21.87
Size: 5 Inches Tall Assorted green, orange, yellow, red, blue and purple Plush material All Ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Plush Toy Mini Bears (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Their small size plush teddy bear is a handful of cuteness. Perfect plush for a party favor bag. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party theme! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. This pack of 12 Plush Toy Mini Bears is perfect for any occasion! With an assortment of colors including green, orange, yellow, red, blue and purple, these 5 inch tall teddy bears are made of soft plush material and are suitable for all ages. As a bonus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Make your next carnival or party a hit with these adorable plush toy mini bears!
Narwhal Plush Toy (1 Dozen) Narwhal Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
US Toy Narwhal Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
$26.73
Inches: 7 Inches Tall Plush 3 assorted styles All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Narwhal Plush (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! The unicorn whale or narwhal is a favorite story book character and animal. Give away these plush as party favors or have them win them as a prize. Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. This dozen pack of narwhal plush toys is perfect for all ages! Featuring our 7 inch tall plush in 3 assorted styles, these adorable toys are sure to be a hit. Delight your guests with these cute narwhal plush as party favors or prizes. Ships from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Explore our Plush Toys category at CarnivalSource.com for more great items!
Sitting Unicorn Plush Toys (pack of 12)
US Toy Sitting Unicorn Plush Toys (pack of 12)
$25.52
Size: 6 Inches Tall Assorted colors Made of plush All Ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Sitting Unicorn Plush (pack of 12) by CarnivalSource.com! No need to teach these unicorns to sit; they already are! A perfect party favor, these sitting unicorn plush bring the fantasy to reality for kids of all ages. Brightly colored, they can be used as party favors or as redemption prizes for the next school carnival. Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. This pack of 12 Sitting Unicorn Plush by CarnivalSource.com is the perfect way to bring fantasy to life! These colorful plush toys feature a 6 inch tall sitting unicorn, perfect for kids of all ages. These make great party favors or redemption prizes for school carnivals. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day. Get ready for a magical time with these Sitting Unicorn Plush!
Plush Toy Animal Assortment (One Dozen)
US Toy Plush Toy Animal Assortment (One Dozen)
$21.87
Size: 4 1/2 Inches Tall Animals have red ribbons around their necks Assortment includes teddy bears, dogs, pandas, koalas, cats, monkeys, bunnies and more All Ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Plush Toy Plush Animal Assortment (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! The wide selection of wild and farm animals in this assortment make them great Carnival Redemption prizes. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party theme! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Our Plush Toy Plush Animal Assortment (One Dozen) is the perfect addition to any carnival or party game. With a variety of wild and farm animals, including teddy bears, dogs, pandas, koalas, cats, monkeys, bunnies and more, kids of all ages will love to win these 4 1/2 inches tall furry friends with red ribbons around their necks. This assortment is shipped from our Missouri warehouse within one business day, and comes in a Poly Bag. Shop our Plush Toys category at CarnivalSource.com for more great items!
Jumbo Scaly Snakes Plush Toy (One dozen) Jumbo Scaly Snakes Plush Toy (One dozen)
US Toy Jumbo Scaly Snakes Plush Toy (One dozen)
$55.08
Size: 48 Inches Long Assorted red, blue, and green scaly designs Plush material All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Jumbo Scaly Snakes (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Scaly snakes that won't shed their skins. They like being cuddled too much for that. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys, you are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party theme! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. These jumbo scaly snakes are the perfect carnival redemption prize! Each one is 48 inches long, with colorful red, blue, and green designs. Crafted from a plush material, these soft toys are suitable for all ages. Plus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Get your dozen today and make sure your next celebration has the perfect prizes!
Dog Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) Dog Finger Puppets (1 Dozen)
US Toy Dog Finger Puppets (1 Dozen)
$9.72
3 1/4 inches Wide 4 inches Long Felt Assorted dog designs Ages 3 yrs+ Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Dog Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Put on a play with this cute dog finger puppet. Kids love a good finger puppet. Our finger puppets are made of soft plush material and fit small and large fingers alike. Put on a puppet play or fill a party favor bag with these loveable puppets. Finger puppets make great carnival redemption prizes too. Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Our Dog Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) are 3 1/4 inches wide and 4 inches long and made of soft felt. With an assortment of dog designs, these finger puppets are perfect for kids ages 3 and up. Perfect for puppet plays or carnival redemption prizes, these puppets ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Each dozen comes in a 9 inches poly bag with a header. Get your set today!
GET A 10% DISCOUNT CODE TO USE ON YOUR FIRST ORDER!

Signup For Our Newsletter and Promotions

By subscribing, I agree to this store's Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy and to receive emails from CarnivalSource.com. I agree that CarnivalSource.com may provide me with personalized advertising via email and other online channels. I have read and agree to the CarnivalSource.com Terms and Conditions and CarnivalSource.com Privacy Policy.

We Appreciate Your Business!

Designed and developed by BoosterTheme™

Mastercard PayPal Shop Pay Visa Google Pay