Carnival Game Supplies Costume Glasses Costume Masks Costume Rings Dinosaur Party Theme Easter Party Supplies Finger Puppets Luau Party Theme Mardi Gras Party Supplies Miscellaneous Toys Neon Party Theme Panda Party Theme Party Noisemakers Pirate Party Theme Plush Toys Puffer Toys Rainbow Party Theme Safari Party Theme School Supplies Erasers School Supplies Pencils and Pens Toy Animals Toy Insects and Bugs Unicorn Party Theme Water Toys Yo-Yos
Ball Toys
best-seller
Carnival Game Supplies
Cats and Dogs
Costume Glasses
Costume Masks
Costume Rings
Costumes and Accessories
Ducks
Easter Novelties
Erasers
extra bulky
Farm Animals
Figurines
Finger Puppets
Frogs
Games
Games and Puzzles
Holidays
Inflatable Toys
Mardi Gras Novelties
Miscellaneous Animals
Miscellaneous Toys
Novelties
oversized/heavy
Party Noisemakers
Party Supplies
Party Themes
Party Themes - Butterfly
Party Themes - Dinosaur
Party Themes - Emoji
Party Themes - Insect
Party Themes - Luau Party
Party Themes - Mermaid
Party Themes - Monkey
Party Themes - Neon
Party Themes - Panda
Party Themes - Pirate Theme
Party Themes - Princess
Party Themes - Rainbow
Party Themes - Safari
Party Themes - Smile Face
Party Themes - Unicorn
Party Themes - Western Theme
Pencil Toppers
Pencils
Pencils and Pens
Plush Toys
Puffer Toys
Reptiles
School Supplies
Snakes
Spiders
Squirt Toys
Stuffed Animals
theme: Alligator
theme: Alligators
theme: Animal
theme: Butterfly
theme: Carnival
theme: Cat
theme: Cats
theme: Costume Rings
theme: Cupcake
theme: Dinosaur
theme: Dog
theme: Dogs
theme: Dragon
theme: Dragons
theme: Ducks
theme: Easter
theme: Farm
theme: Insects
theme: Jungle
theme: Keychain
theme: Llama
theme: Luau
theme: Mardi Gras
theme: Mermaids
theme: Neon
theme: Panda
theme: Pirate
theme: Plush
theme: Puffer Toys
theme: Rainbow
theme: School
theme: Shark
theme: Sharks
theme: Smile
theme: Snake
theme: Snakes
theme: Summer
theme: Toy Animals
theme: Under the Sea
theme: Unicorn
theme: Woodland
Toy Animals
Toy Assortments
Toy Bugs
Toy Water Creatures
Toys
Water Toys
Wild Animals
Worms
Yo-Yos
Dinosaur Tracers Party Favor - 48 Pieces Dinosaur Tracers Party Favor - 48 Pieces
US Toy Dinosaur Tracers Party Favor - 48 Pieces
$5.67
Size 3 3/4 inches Long Made of plastic Assorted colors, styles Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Dino Tracers - 48 Pieces by CarnivalSource.com! Draw a masterpiece with the assistance of this dino tracer. Add this fun stationery item to a goody bag or hand out as a carnival prize. 48 pieces per pack. Find more great items like this in our Dinosaur Party Theme category here at CarnivalSource.com. Dino Tracers - 48 Pieces by CarnivalSource.com is the perfect way to create a prehistoric masterpiece! With 48 pieces made of plastic in assorted colors and styles, kids can draw and color for hours. Shipping from our Missouri warehouse within one business day, each piece measures 3 3/4 inches Long Add to a goody bag or hand out as a carnival prize - find more dinosaur-themed items in our Dinosaur Party Theme category!
Sold out
Crocodile - 6 Inch Plush Toy (One dozen) Crocodile - 6 Inch Plush Toy (One dozen)
US Toy Crocodile - 6 Inch Toy (One dozen)
$6.48
Size 6 inches Long Made of plastic Assorted colors Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Crocodile - 6 Inch (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Watch out! A dangerously hungry crocodile lurks just under the surface of the water. This toy animal figure will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com. These Crocodile - 6 Inch toys are perfect for any themed party! Made of plastic and measuring 6 inches in length, they come in assorted colors and ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Great for goody bags and carnival prizes, these fun animal figures will bring any event to life. Get your dozen today from CarnivalSource.com!
Sold out
Jumping Frogs Toy - 36 Pieces Jumping Frogs Toy - 36 Pieces
US Toy Jumping Frogs Toy - 36 Pieces
$3.24
Size: 2 Inches Long Made of plastic Assorted colors Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Jumping Frogs - 36 Pieces by CarnivalSource.com! Press on his tail and watch this toy frog jump. This toy animal figure will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. 36 pieces per pack. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com. Our Jumping Frogs - 36 Pieces are the perfect addition to any themed party. Made of plastic, these 2-inch frogs come in assorted colors and will make your guests jump for joy when they press on their tails. Ships from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. With 36 pieces per pack, these toy animals are great for goody bags or carnival prizes. Shop our Toy Animals category for more exciting finds!
Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen)
US Toy Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen)
$8.10
3 1/4 Inches Wide x 4 Inches Long Felt Assorted wild animal designs including giraffe, zebra, lion, tiger, leopard, and elephant Ages 3 yrs+ Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! This wild animal finger puppet is perfect for pretend play. Celebrate in wild style with an animal print theme. Whether your theme is jungle, zoo, safari or wild animal we have the selection of party favors and costume accessories your need to make your adventure night a roaring success! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Wild Animal Finger Puppets (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com is perfect for pretend play. These assorted wild animal designs including giraffe, zebra, lion, tiger, leopard, and elephant will bring your wild animal theme to life. Made from felt and measuring 3 1/4 inches Wide 4 inches Long, these finger puppets are the perfect party favor for ages 3 yrs+. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day, and arrives in a 9 inches Poly Bag w/ header. Shop CarnivalSource.com for more great items from our Plush Toys category!
Animal Pencil Wraps (One Dozen)
US Toy Animal Pencil Wraps (One Dozen)
$3.32
Highlights: Animal-shaped pencil wraps will add some fun to your writing assignments Made of plastic Sizes range from 1.13 Inches Long to 2 Inches Long Package 12 pieces with Assorted Styles Safety Rating - Age 3+ Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day These Animal Pencil Wraps by CarnivalSource.com are perfect for adding a bit of fun to any classroom or carnival. Each wrap is made of plastic and ranges in size from 1.13 Inches Long to 2 Inches Long Assorted styles are included in each dozen, and each order ships from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. With the 12 Pencil Wraps, these pencil wraps are great for any occasion. Shop now in our School Supplies Pencils and Pens category!
Turtle Squirters Toy (One Dozen) Turtle Squirters Toy (One Dozen)
US Toy Turtle Squirters Toy (One Dozen)
$5.54
Made of soft plastic Assorted colors (colors may vary) Size: 1.75 Inches Long Ages 3 yrs+ Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Turtle Squirters (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Small but mighty, these turtle squirters will have your young guests giddy with delight. This turtle water toy squirts water from his mouth when given a good squeeze. Makes a perfect party favor giveaway during those hot summer months. Also a great way to liven up bath time. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com.`Turtle Squirters (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com are the perfect party favor for your summer events! Made of soft plastic, these turtles come in assorted colors and measure 1 3/4 inches Long Perfect for ages 3 and up, these squirters will make bath time and outdoor play more fun. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day! Get your Turtle Squirters today!
Sold out
Jumbo Reptiles Toy (36 Pack) Jumbo Reptiles Toy (36 Pack)
US Toy Jumbo Reptiles Toy (36 Pack)
$2.30
Size: 2 Inches Long Assorted colors Assorted styles Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Jumbo Reptiles (36 Pack) by CarnivalSource.com! Assorted toy reptiles ready to play. This toy animal figure will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. 36 pieces per pack. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com. This 36-pack of jumbo reptiles is perfect for any themed party. The assortment includes a variety of colors and styles, measuring 2 inches in length. With fast shipping from our Missouri warehouse, these toys can be at your door in no time. Perfect for goody bags or carnival prizes, these toy animals are sure to bring life to any event. Get your own Jumbo Reptiles (36 Pack) today from CarnivalSource.com!
Sold out
Mardi Gras Bears Toy (One dozen) Mardi Gras Bears Toy (One dozen)
US Toy Mardi Gras Bears Toy (12 Bears Per Package)
$28.08
Plush bears 7 Inches Tall x 4 Inches Wide x 2.5 Inches Deep Wearing crowns All ages This is a seasonal item and not stocked year-round Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Mardi Gras Bears (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Stuffed animal bears that are ready to party! These crown-wearing Mardi Gras bears make a unique party favor. Mardi Gras celebrations won't be complete unless your guests can have a prize to take home with them. Fill their loot bags up with fun Mardi Gras party favors so they will always remember the fun they had. Find more great items like this in our Mardi Gras Party Supplies category here at CarnivalSource.com. Celebrate Mardi Gras with a dozen plush bears! These 7 inch tall bears come wearing crowns and make a great party favor for all ages. These festive bears are perfect for any Mardi Gras celebration, and they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Get your Mardi Gras Bears (One dozen) today at CarnivalSource.com!
Mini Shark And Whale Toy Set (One dozen) Mini Shark And Whale Toy Set (One dozen)
US Toy Mini Shark And Whale Toy Set (One dozen)
$3.24
Size 3 inches Long Made of soft plastic Assorted styles Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Mini Shark And Whale (One dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Toy sharks and whales in authentic looking colors and designs. This toy animal figure will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com. This Mini Shark and Whale set is perfect for any themed party! Made of soft plastic, these 3 inches figures come in assorted styles and colors. Give them away as prizes or fill up goody bags with these fun toy animals! Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com.
Wild Animals with Velcro Hands Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
US Toy Wild Animals with Velcro Hands Plush Toy (1 Dozen)
$32.40
Highlights: 11 inches Tall Assortment includes: Tiger, Zebra, lion and Elephant Hook & loop palms Plush material All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Our Wild Animals with Velcro Hands (1 Dozen) is a perfect addition to any safari-themed party! Our 11 inch tall assortment includes a tiger, zebra, lion, and elephant, all with hook & loop palms. They are made of a plush material, perfect for all ages. Plus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Perfect for a school or church carnival or redemption center, these wild animals are the perfect prize for your next celebration. Get your set today!
Sold out
Mini Tree Frogs Toy Set (One Dozen) Mini Tree Frogs Toy Set (One Dozen)
US Toy Mini Tree Frogs Toy Set (One Dozen)
$2.91
Size 2.5 Inches Long Made of plastic Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Mini Tree Frogs (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! This realistic looking mini tree frog toy is a perfect pocket size. This toy animal figure will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com. Bring the outdoors into your home with our Mini Tree Frogs (One Dozen)! These realistic plastic figures measure 2.5 inches long and are perfect for parties, goody bags, or carnival prizes. This product ships from our Missouri warehouse within one business day and is packaged with a 6 inches Poly Bag with a header. Shop our Toy Animals category for more great items like this!
Dinosaurs Toy - 48 Pieces Dinosaurs Toy - 48 Pieces
US Toy Dinosaurs Toy - 48 Pieces
$7.77
Size 2 1/4 inches Long Made of plastic Assorted colors Assorted styles Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Dinosaurs - 48 Pieces by CarnivalSource.com! These toy dinosaurs are small enough to fit in your pocket. This toy dino figure will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. 48 pieces per pack. Find more great items like this in our Dinosaur Party Theme category here at CarnivalSource.com. Dinosaurs - 48 Pieces by CarnivalSource.com are perfect for any dinosaur-themed party! These plastic toy dinosaurs come in assorted colors and styles, and measure 2 1/4 inches long. They're perfect for goody bags, prizes, or just as a fun toy. Get your hands on this 48-piece pack quickly, as it ships from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Shop our Dinosaur Party Theme category for more great items!
Worms Toy Set (One Dozen) Worms Toy Set (One Dozen)
US Toy Worms Toy Set (One Dozen)
$2.84
Highlights: Size: 5.5 Inches Long Made of rubber Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Our Worms (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com are the perfect addition to any themed party or goody bag. Measuring 5.5 inches long and made of rubber, these realistic worms are sure to bring a smile to any child's face. Our fast shipping from our Missouri warehouse ensures your order is within one business day. Shop our Toy Animals category for more fun items like these worms.
Cats - 4 Inch Plush Toy (One Dozen)
US Toy Cats - 4 Inch Toy (One Dozen)
$6.62
Size: 4 Inches Long Made of plastic Assorted styles Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Cats - 4 Inch (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! Keep these cats nearby if you need some furry friends. This toy animal figure will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com. Add some fun to your next event with these Cats - 4 Inch (One Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These plastic cats come in assorted styles and measure 4 inches long. Perfect for a themed party, goody bag, or as prizes for a school or church carnival. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day. Get your dozen cats today and make your event purrfect!
Mini Ice Age Animal Assortment Toy 12 pieces Mini Ice Age Animal Assortment Toy 12 pieces
US Toy Mini Ice Age Animal Assortment Toy 12 pieces
$4.86
Includes 12 animals in 8 assorted styles Styles: Saber Tooth Tiger, Giant Sloth, Musk Ox, Mastodon, (back row); Ice Age Armadillo, Woolly Rhino , Ice Age Aardvark (middle row); Woolly Mammoth, (front row) Size: approximately 2 inches long Made of plastic Ages 3 yrs.+ Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Mini Ice Age Animal Assortment 12 pieces by CarnivalSource.com! Bring back the Ice Age with this assortment of prehistoric animal figures. Miniature in size, they fit nicely into goody bags for themed parties, or give them away at your next church carnival. They also make the perfect addition for your child's diorama in their next school project!Find more great items like this in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com.
Yellow Ducks Toy (1 Dozen) Yellow Ducks Toy (1 Dozen)
US Toy Yellow Ducks Toy (1 Dozen)
$6.48
Highlights: Rubber Vinyl Yellow Ducky 2.5 inches Long x 2 inches Wide x 2. 25 Inches Tall Will float but won't float upright Ages 3+ Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day These classic yellow vinyl rubber ducks by CarnivalSource.com make a perfect addition to any game, party favor, or bath time fun. Each duck measures 2.5 inches Long x 2 inches Wide x 2. 25 Inches Tall and will float but not upright. Suitable for ages 3 and up, these ducks ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Find more fun toy animals in our Toy Animals category here at CarnivalSource.com - one dozen ducks come in a poly bag.
Sold out
Plush Parrots Toy (1 Dozen) Plush Parrots Toy (1 Dozen)
US Toy Plush Parrots Toy (1 Dozen)
$49.95
12 Inches long from head to tail Assorted red, green and blue colors Plush material All ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Plush Parrots (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These colorful parrots are "stuffed" with fun. Use them to decorate for a Luau party and pose one on a shoulder to complete a pirate costume. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party theme! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. Brighten up your next party with Plush Parrots (1 Dozen)! These fun parrots come in assorted colors of red, green and blue and measure 12 inches from head to tail. Crafted from plush material, they're perfect for all ages and make great prizes for carnival games. Plus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day. Get your parrots in a poly bag today!
Sold out
Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen) Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen)
US Toy Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen)
$20.52
Size: 5 1/2 Inches Tall Sitting position Assorted red, blue, brown, gray, green and purple colors Plush material All Ages Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs (1 Dozen) by CarnivalSource.com! These plush bull dogs are begging for you to take them home. Sitting pretty as you please, these stuffed animal dogs are fun addition to any party favor bag. Every carnival or party game needs a great prize. Plush stuffed animals are the ultimate carnival redemption prize. Kids of all ages love to win these furry creatures. So when you plan your next celebration make sure you have a prize for all your games. With our wide selection of plush toys your are sure to find the perfect gift or prize to fit your party theme! Find more great items like this in our Plush Toys category here at CarnivalSource.com. This pack of Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs is the perfect prize or gift for any celebration! These adorable stuffed animals come in an assortment of colors including red, blue, brown, gray, green and purple. Measuring 5.5 inches tall and made of a soft plush material, these Bull Dogs are suitable for all ages. Plus, they ship from our Missouri warehouse within one business day! Perfect for party favor bags, carnival redemption prizes, and more! Get your Plush Multicolor Bull Dogs today from CarnivalSource.com!
Animal Noses Party Favor (One Dozen) Animal Noses Party Favor (One Dozen)
US Toy Animal Noses Party Favor (One Dozen)
$9.72
Highlights: Pretend you're an animal with these assorted animal noses! Elastic Band For Fastening Made of Soft Plastic Item sizes range from 2 Inches Long to 3 Inches Long Assorted Noses: Pig, Dog, Walrus, Rhinoceros, Bunny, Alligator, Shark, Cat, and Boar Safety Rating - Age 3+ 12 Noses Per Package Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day Animal Noses (One Dozen) from CarnivalSource.com is the perfect way to explore your wild side! This set includes a range from 2 Inches Long to 3 Inches long plastic noses in 12 fun animal shape, including elephant, pig, dog, walrus, rhinoceros, bunny, alligator, shark, cat, and boar. Elastic bands attach the nose to your face for a realistic look. Ideal for dress-up and pretend play, these Animal Noses are recommended for ages 3 and up. Ships from Missouri warehouse within one business day.
Sold out
Assorted Toy Sharks (1 Dozen) Assorted Toy Sharks (1 Dozen)
US Toy Assorted Toy Sharks (1 Dozen)
$7.77
Highlights: Realistic Looking Sharks! Made of Soft Plastic 12 Toy Sharks Per Package Includes Hammerhead Shark, Great White Shark, Angel Shark, Zebra Bullhead Shark, Tiger Shark, Whale Shark, Thresher Shark, Goblin Shark Size: 3 Inches Long Safety Rating - Age 3+ CarnivalSource.com Exclusive! Product Description: This toy shark will make any themed party come alive. Animal figures are fun for any goody bag or as prizes for a school or church carnival. Product Highlights: Size approx 3 inches long. Made of soft plastic, Assorted styles, Carnival Source Exclusive!This product category is perfect for any themed party or event. Our dozen assorted toy sharks are made of soft plastic and measure approximately 3 inches in length. With a variety of styles to choose from, these sharks are an exclusive Carnival Source product and are sure to be a hit!

We Appreciate Your Business!

CarnivalSource.com is operated by Online Party Sales LLC. Murrieta, California, USA

© 2026 Online Party Sales LLC. All rights reserved.